do it for mom
Tuesday, September 15, 2009 at 09:55PM My mother died four years ago this week. She battled brain tumors for a decade, and with some help and hand wringing had the coverage she needed to undergo nine brain surgeries.
When she died she was 54.
It is this about this time every year when I try and write about her. It's tough. I have so many ideas and memories and I struggle to get them all in one functional place, the page. This year it's been more difficult than ever because I'm bothered. I shouldn't get this way. I should be above the fray, but the so-called debate over health care reform has me outraged. Or maybe sad, I can't tell. Regardless, after what my mom went through, it's hard to see people who will no doubt have loved ones endure similar battles buy the story that a public option has anything to do with Socialism, or that encouraging people to get living wills is even close to the mythical "death panels".
First, please let me apologize to my mom. I have great stories to share about you, and I will, but right now I've got to cover a brief history of the smear campaign. If you remember mom, we spoke of this when I suckered you into helping me with my 2004 political action committee HELP, or Help Evict this Lousy President. If that's any consolation to you...or, really, me.
Invoking socialism into fight over health care reform is the equivalent of calling our military, with their health care covered by taxpayer money, Socialist. And what about the 80 million Americans who depend on government subsidies for their care? Socialists. And the Republican Presidential candidate Mitt Romney who mandated everyone in the state of Massachusetts have health care? Socialist. Or, even better, wouldn't the bankers who were bailed out by taxpayer money be engaged in Socialism? The argument is futile. It’s only an emotional button to motivate a reaction. From a political stand point it works, but what a smear campaign really does is further exhaust a nation already weary of recession and war. Instead of working towards a solution with an honest debate, we’re lead around by scoundrels with bad intentions.
To show exactly where these smear tactics have taken us, please let me offer some recent public melees and their results.
In the 2000 Republican Primary evangelicals for George W. Bush call conservative voters and suggest Bush opponent John McCain has had a black child out of wedlock. In 2001 Treasury Secretary Paul O’ Neill cites a survey saying tax cuts will drive the nation into debt. He is fired and characterized as an unstable man with a grudge. In 2003 people who question the need for a war in Iraq are painted as unpatriotic and anti-troop. In 2004 George W. Bush buddy and billionaire oilman T. Boone Pickens funds the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth to attack John Kerry about the validity of his Vietnam medals.
And what happened in all of these cases?
- The black child of McCain’s turned out to be a Bangladeshi girl he and his wife had adopted from Mother Theresa’s orphanage (that’s got to a direct shot to Hades.)
- While Paul O’ Neill’s character was attacked, taxes were cut, America slid into debt and important mandates went unfunded.
- The war in Iraq commenced with America’s media so focused on the question of patriotism that today American military generals have criticized news organization for not properly reporting the consequences of the invasion.
- Veterans included in the swift boat attack ads eventually apologized for being a part of it. Even John McCain, already familiar with smears, called the swift boat ads “dishonorable and dishonest” and asked the Bush administration to call an end to it.
Pickens eventually invested in wind energy.
The point of a smear campaign is to distract. It’s a coordinated plan to change the argument. Right now America needs a serious discussion about health care, but desperate politicians supported by millions in insurance and pharmaceutical money have taken the conversation to dark alley for a fistfight. There will be no enlightenment here, as instead of talking about how to make our health care system better, we’re bickering over Socialism.
Health care reform is about people. It's about happy kids, content retirees and the well being of everybody in between. It's also about money, and with the average premium skyrocketing 80% over the past nine years, it's about time. Unfortunately, however, many of the same men and women who tout America for its opportunity and its freedoms, its wealth and its power, are holding our health hostage with a despicable debate trick.
But perhaps it's not entirely the fault of those who have altered the argument to meaningless epithets and baseless fear mongering. Maybe it's those who are sitting on their hands and only waiting for something better for the American people. Because it isn’t just politicians and lobbyists who can change the argument. We can too.
In 2004, when my mom was being wheeled away for her ninth brain surgery, a nurse jokingly said, "Wow, you must know somebody!"
Will you?
ewy |
4 Comments | 